"And here's what may be the deepest existential problem with the child-man – a tendency to avoid not just marriage but any deep attachments. This is British writer Nick Hornby's central insight in his novel About a Boy. The book's anti-hero, Will, is an SYM whose life is as empty of passion as of responsibility. He has no self apart from pop-culture effluvia, a fact that the author symbolizes by having the jobless 36-year-old live off the residuals of a popular Christmas song written by his late father. Mr. Hornby shows how the media-saturated limbo of contemporary guyhood makes it easy to fill your days without actually doing anything.
Will's unemployment is part of a more general passionlessness. To pick up women, for instance, he pretends to have a son and joins a single-parent organization; the plight of the single mothers means nothing to him. For Will, women are simply fleshy devices that dispense sex, and sex is just another form of entertainment, a "fantastic carnal alternative to drink, drugs and a great night out, but nothing much more than that."
The superficiality, indolence and passionlessness evoked in Mr. Hornby's novels haven't triggered any kind of cultural transformation. The SYM doesn't read much, remember, and he certainly doesn't read anything prescribing personal transformation. The child-man may be into self-mockery; self-reflection is something else entirely.
That's too bad. Young men especially need a culture that can help them define worthy aspirations.
Adults don't emerge. They're made."
I would have condensed the quote, but I felt that each piece is necessary to understand how ridiculous the next one is. I especially how Hymowitz says the SYM's (Me) don't read. I mean, most of her demographic (the SYMS) are only comprised of college students or recent college graduates, and we all know that they don't read, right?
Honestly, I wouldn't have brought up this article at all if it weren't for one major thing. Hymowitz bases her most controversial argument (that SYMS not only avoid "marriage, but any deep attachments") is based off of About A Boy. A novel, that was later turned into a movie. As a college student, and an English major I find actual physical pain in her use of a novel as evidence of a real-world phenomena. Fiction ≠ Evidence. Since this, her only piece of evidence for her final argument is complete bunk, then the rest must be as well, and thus I just don't give a shit.
-Cory Ragsdale